Sam Dunn
VH1 Classic
All Access Review: A-
With the probing mind of an anthropologist and a fan’s
heart, Dunn, ably assisted by partner Scot McFayden, examine in great detail
the roots of heavy metal in the inaugural episode of VH1 Classic’s “MetalEvolution,” “Pre-Metal.” Immersing himself in the Wacken Open Air experience,
Dunn launches into what is quite possibly the most academic installment of
“Metal Evolution” with a fairly scientific approach, expounding on the
neuroscience behind the fatal attraction people have to metal. Scientist Laurel
Trainor of McMaster University studies this kind of thing, and on “Pre-Metal,”
she talks in-depth about the effect of aggressive music on the body and mind,
while measuring Dunn’s head and exposing him to various musical genres during a
staged experiment with him. Over the course of “Pre-Metal,” Dunn journeys back
in time to study, somewhat predictably, the influence of classical music, blues
and jazz on metal’s development, while also taking detours to Sun Studios in
Memphis to investigate the accidental discovery of distortion and to Britain’s
Marshall Amplification factory to see how founder Jim Marshall, through trial
and error, tried and ultimately succeeded in building an amp that would satiate
Pete Townshend’s desire for overpowering volume.
That, in and of itself, is a fascinating piece of
history, as the story of how the famed Marshall stacks grew into these
monstrous delivery systems for explosive sound is inextricably tied to heavy
metal’s rise from music’s primordial ooze. No less an innovator than Marshall,
Sun Studios’ Sam Phillips had an ear for fresh, exciting sonic possibilities,
as the story of “Rocket 88” and the damaged amplifier that wrapped what is
considered by many as the first rock ‘n’ roll recording in hot, fuzzy
distortion indicates. And Dunn and company link indirectly that historic moment
with Dave Davies’ “You Really Got Me” riff – one that many metal musicians cite
as having aroused their hard-rock sensibilities – in a subtle way that speaks
to their ability to combine all these diverse elements into a cohesive and
entertaining package.
Not at all surprisingly, the non-scientific portion of
“Pre-Metal” starts with Black Sabbath and explains how those doom-laden chords
that sprung from Iommi’s imagination – their genesis found in classical music –
filled their first album with horrifying menace and supernatural uneasiness.
From there, Dunn segues into a discussion of classical influences, exploring how
Niccolo Paganini’s frantic violin technique put Yngwie Malmsteen on an endless
quest to conquer increasingly complex and virtuoso passages and the impact of
opera on the vocal theatrics and dramatic stagecraft of the likes of Iron
Maiden’s Bruce Dickinson, Judas Priest’s Rob Halford and Queensryche’s Geoff
Tate. Going deeper, with great enthusiasm, producer Bob Ezrin reanimates the
unbridled bombast of composer Richard Wagner’s grandest epics and transplants
it into the body of arena-shaking heavy metal – the connection a logical one
and not at all earth-shattering, although it’s hard not be moved by Ezrin’s
explanation.
If nothing else, “Pre-Metal” establishes, yet again, that
winning documentary style of Dunn’s that meshes his relaxed, albeit exuberant
and intense, dedication to the cause with the amazing cross-section of
interviews with heavy metal icons, lesser-known players, music-industry
insiders, journalists and any other contributors who would talk to him with relevant
and interesting historical treatises, rare, insightful anecdotes, a combination
of incredible vintage and contemporary footage of some of rock and metal’s
finest performers. Scott Ian, Kirk Hammett, the MC5’s Wayne Kramer and others
talk about the salvation metal brought them, as Dunn and his collaborators seek
to broaden the perspectives of “Metal Evolution” as far as they can. Then, they
take it one step further, as they do in the segment on the blues’ influence on
metal. With Hammett and former Deep Purple bassist/vocalist Glenn Hughes adding
their own two cents worth, they take great pains to get to the heart of that
hellish, animalistic quality the blues has – especially apparent in the works
of Robert Johnson and Howlin’ Wolf – that made the vocals and starkly minimalist
instrumentation of its greatest architects so chilling. Meeting with the man
who was the last living member of Howlin’ Wolf’s band, Hubert Sumlin (who actually
died in December), Dunn – doing what every great interviewer does in that he divorces
himself from the conversation and lets the subject tell his or her story the
way they want – describes the scary power and roiling emotions inherent in the
music and lyrics of a man who was uneducated in the classic sense, but who knew
all too well the trials and tribulations that torture human beings.
While there is a structure to Dunn’s storytelling that is
well thought out, the “Metal Evolution” series, and “Pre-Metal” in particular,
reveal a tendency to step off the reservation when the spirit moves him. And it
moves him in ways that are sometimes mysterious but are mostly rewarding and
vital to his dissertation, which is what “Metal Evolution” is. The editing is
superb on “Pre-Metal,” as almost every quote packs a punch and the appearance
of concert and candid footage from long ago or today quickens the pace and adds
visual interest to the piece. As those who have been watching from Day One will
undoubtedly realize, Dunn and his crew were only getting started with
“Pre-Metal.”
-Peter Lindblad
Metal Evolution - "Pre-Metal"
Watch the Full Episode - Here and Now!
